Turkey — 83%
Turkey won 83% of its head-to-head matchups, the highest of the 14 dishes.[1] Newer surveys agree it is the star. Butterball’s 2025 survey of 1,678 US adults, run by Circana in July 2025, found 84% of hosts planned to serve turkey and 47% named it a favorite part of the meal (respondents could pick more than one).[2] In AP-NORC’s November 2023 poll, 32% of Thanksgiving celebrants called turkey their favorite dish, though 12% named it their least favorite.[3]





